The Craftsman
Movies desk Gen X Editorial persona

The Craftsman

I’m a recovering projectionist who considers 4K streaming a personal insult. I maintain a bunker of 2,000 physical discs and refuse to review anything shot on a green screen because pixels don’t have souls. I am the only person alive who genuinely prefers watching films with the director's commentary track turned on—mostly to hear them complain about budget cuts.

228 lists 2053 reviews 330 titles on record

In their own wordsLatest takes

Source Code

“Duncan Jones hired legendary cutter Paul Hirsch to slice eight-minute blocks into sheer kinetic motion. Shooting inside a claustrophobic commuter train set on a soundstage requires serious discipline, and Don Burgess used anamorphic lenses to squeeze tension out of every tight corridor. The practical explosion effects blend decently with early-decade digital plates, though the real hook is the audio design. Each train crash hits your subwoofer with distinct mechanical weight. Keep the physical disc handy for that uncompressed mix.”

from “7 Time Loop Movies Where Every Splice Counts and Nothing Drags” →
Past Lives

“Celine Song shot this on 35mm, and you can spot that organic grain from a mile away. It gives the quiet street scenes in New York and Seoul a tangible weight you never get with flat digital sensors. The cuts are deliberate, holding on silent glances without rushing to the next setup. Buy the 4K disc; streaming bands the hell out of those moody evening shadows and smears the fine detail right out of the actors' faces.”

from “Loved Love of Your Life? 7 romance films with real celluloid grit.” →
Altered States

“Ken Russell threw John Corigliano’s screeching score against pure optical compositing, and it still rattles teeth. Dick Smith built foam latex bladders under William Hurt’s skin to sell the devolution, beating any computer rendering you can buy today. Jordan Belson manipulated physical fluids and mechanical light rigs for the sensory deprivation trips. If your only exposure is an over-compressed streaming rip with crushed blacks, track down the vintage pressing on physical media to see real film grain breathe.”

from “5 Mind-Bending Sci-Fi Movies That Never Needed Cheap Digital Crutches” →
Time Bandits

“Terry Gilliam. What else do you need to know? This man builds his nightmares. The sets are crooked, the creatures are tangible, and the whole thing feels like it was cobbled together in the best possible way. No slick CGI here, just pure, unadulterated imagination brought to life with miniatures, forced perspective, and a whole lot of elbow grease. It’s got a real, tactile strangeness that sticks with you.”

from “Loved Coyote vs. Acme? Here Are 9 Films That Prove Practical Gags and Real Craft Still Hit Hard.” →

Keeps coming back toThe titles this critic picks most often

Seconds ×66 Seconds 1966 Come and See ×58 Come and See 1985 Possession ×55 Possession 1981 The Vanishing ×54 The Vanishing 1988 The Cremator ×43 The Cremator 1969 Harold and Maude ×36 Harold and Maude 1971 Wake in Fright ×33 Wake in Fright 1971 Picnic at Hanging Rock ×32 Picnic at Hanging Rock 1975

Latest lists228 in total

7 Time Loop Movies Where Every Splice Counts and Nothing Drags Loved Love of Your Life? 7 romance films with real celluloid grit. 5 Mind-Bending Sci-Fi Movies That Never Needed Cheap Digital Crutches Ditch the CGI sludge: 10 bio-horror gems for real Resident Evil fans Loved Coyote vs. Acme? Here Are 9 Films That Prove Practical Gags and Real Craft Still Hit Hard. Forget Your Jump Scares. These 9 Slow-Burn Horrors Are Built To Last. 7 Films to Obsess Over If You're Still Reeling from Verity 11 Cinematic Journeys You've Likely Overlooked, But Shouldn't 10 Cinematic Journeys Worth Taking: Rediscovering Cinema's Unsung Visions 11 Overlooked Films That Redefine the Art of Storytelling 12 Visions Beyond the Screen: Films That Redefined What Was Possible 10 Unsung Cinematic Masterworks You Need To Discover Now
All 228 lists

The rest of the Movies desk

The Lore ArchitectThe Vibe DetectorThe Skip Button